Friday, September 27, 2024

Nancy Kilpatrick: "The Case of the Demon Lover," "Sustenance" and "Going Down"

I warned you this might happen so I hope you are ready--today we read three stories by Nancy Kilpatrick which--I think--are going to be about women having sex with monsters!  All courtesy of the internet archive, world's greatest website!   

"The Case of the Demon Lover" (1996)

I'm reading this in The Best American Erotica: 1997, but I think it debuted in 1996's Noirotica: An Anthology of Erotic Crime Stories.  Noirotica also features a story co-written by Poppy Z. Brite, whose "Calcutta: Lord of Nerves," and "Homewrecker" I liked.  Noirotica also has a pretentious and hilarious introduction by editor Thomas Roche in which he talks about how Raymond Chandler is his inspiration and he is using erotica to reveal important truths about our hypocritical world.  Sure, buddy. 

Adrian hates all men!  She won awards for being a great cop when she worked up in Philly, but now she is working in New Orleans, and her partner is a fat slob with a Southern accent whom she thinks looks like a toad.  They are cruising around, looking for a man who has raped 24 women of all races and social classes, but it ain't easy, as none of the victims can offer any description of their assailant.  Or maybe they are refusing to offer any description....

Adrian takes a walk, leaving her partner behind, and ends up in a cemetery.  We learn a little about her background as daughter of a single mother and a person who is smarter and more competent than everybody else, and how she came to find men repellant.  She discovers the rapist--the most beautiful man she has ever seen!  He uses his magic powers to seduce her--she begs for him to take her, and she has over a dozen orgasms as he uses her!  He is no rapist--all those two dozen women begged to be used by him just as our Adrian is begging!  I guess the multi-page sex scene is meant to appeal to women who have fantasies of being submissive.

Even more than staking her vagina, this newly claimed territory left her feeling owned.  She offered herself up to him in complete submission, and he accepted the offering as if it were his right to take her.  As if she existed to be taken, which was how she felt. 
The story ends with the indication that this man is now her master and they will meet again, she wearing whatever he tells her to wear and doing whatever he tells her to do.  Adrian is the horniest woman this sexual athlete and erotic artist has ever met--she needs multiple treatments to achieve satisfaction!

This isn't bad for porn that flatters women's resentment of men at the same time it appeals to their desire to be dominated by men, especially if you like the idea of degrading sex in the dirt of a cemetery.  A little copyediting would have helped, though--people generally don't say "gun handle," they say "pistol grip."  We'll blame that on Thomas Roche.

"Sustenance" (1993)

This story debuted in 1993 in After Hours, a small press magazine, and would be reprinted in The Vampire Stories of Nancy Kilpatrick.  I'm reading it in M. Christian's Eros ex machina: Eroticizing the Mechanical.  Mr. Christian's book includes a story by prominent SF writer Mike Resnick, so don't think I am going far afield today in blogging about three pornographic stories--there is a lot of overlap in the world of genre, so this post is no more crazy than my posts about detective stories by Leigh Brackett, Henry Kuttner or Fredric Brown.  The intro to Eros ex machina is deliberately funny, a three page warning like the warnings you find in the manuals of appliances and electronics:
Neither Rhinoceros Books nor the editor of Eros ex machina: Eroticizing the Mechanical acknowledges responsibility for any accidental injuries resulting form the unauthorized and/or inappropriate use of this product.
"Sustenance" is the diary of a prisoner.  Our narrator was raped by a robot in an alley (she had many orgasms) and imprisoned in a stone cell to be raped every 24 hours by a robot (she has many orgasms.)  Life in the cell is so boring she comes to welcome the rape, which she calls "the feeding," which I guess is the tenuous vampire angle.  All day she hears noises from one of the walls--is it another prisoner digging through, erroneously thinking our heroine's cell is the outside world?  Eventually the fellow prisoner busts through--it is a robot in the shape of a woman!  The rape robot rapes them both at the same time, and our narrator enjoys watching her fellow rape victim being used at the same time she is being used, reminding her of how her boyfriend used to enjoy watching porn.

Like "The Case of the Demon Lover," "Sustenance" is about a woman who was disappointed by real men and has come to find sexual satisfaction through having sex with a monster, satisfaction she would not have found on her own, but only after being taken by force.   

This story is actually pretty good; Kilpatrick's depiction of the narrator's evolving psychology as she responds to developments in her sanity-busting situation and her descriptions of the smell of metal and of the expanding hole between the cells are effective.  Of course, a story in which a woman comes to appreciate being raped--by a robot!--until her orifices bleed is not for everybody.  

"Going Down"

This one debuted in Mondo Zombie, alongside a new story by Robert Bloch which I will likely get around to reading some day, and has reappeared in other zombie anthologies, including in one featuring a story by George R. R. Martin.  Kilpatrick hits the big time with this one!

"Going Down" is by far the most literary (i. e., most oblique, hardest to understand, and least plot-driven) of today's stories, and the most disgusting and depressing.  There are also lots of jokes that are not funny.  

Paddy is, I think, a small-time actress who, I guess, appeared in B-movies before the zombie apocalypse, and was sexually abused by her father and took lots of drugs for her psychological problems.  Nowadays she is the sole living human in a world of animated corpses, and wishes she would turn into a zombie herself, but her efforts to commit suicide fail and the zombies of her father and her neighbors don't want to kill or eat her.  She has hallucinations of Marilyn Monroe visiting her (dearest Marilyn masturbates with a Twinkie during one such visit.)  The story ends when Paddy eats her father's rotting penis.

Thumbs down for this one.  The big time is not what it is cracked up to be.


**********

All three of these stories are about men treating women badly, how men both fail to meet women's sexual needs and also treat women as sex objects to satisfy their own needs--ironically, the women in the stories are most satisfied when they are most exploited, most objectified.  Is Kilpatrick suggesting that women's minds have been warped by our patriarchal society ("Going Down" in particular, but "The Case of the Demon Lover" as well, take aim at big institutions--the entertainment industry in the former and law enforcement in the latter--for misusing or abusing women) to the point that women are complicit in their own oppression?  Or is Kilpatrick simply recognizing that women's biological makeup is such that they crave domination?    

**********

Well, we did it; we read a story about a police officer raped by some kind of voodoo wizard (she enjoyed it) and a story about a woman raped by a robot (she enjoyed it) and a story abut a woman having an incestuous relationship with a zombie (I guess she enjoyed it?)  Nancy Kilpatrick has a large body of work but I think a little bit of it goes a long way and you shouldn't expect to catch me reading any more of her oeuvre any time soon.    

Thursday, September 26, 2024

Lester del Rey: "Though Poppies Grow," "Lunar Landing," and "Fifth Freedom"

It has been a month since we have talked about Lester del Rey, but we haven't forgotten about him.  Let's today continue reading 1975's Early del Rey, a book of short stories and autobiographical reflections about del Rey's career and relationships with other SF figures, in particular the editor of Astounding and Unknown, John W. Campbell, Jr.

"Though Poppies Grow" (1942)

In introductory passages, Del Rey talks about how he tried to come up with a story responding to American participation to World War II and produced this story, which he had to alter to get Campbell to publish it in Unknown, and how it is "dated...and the world can no longer react properly" to it.  Well, let's see if we can agree with Campbell's criticisms of and/or del Rey's belief that 1975 people wouldn't know how to respond to "Though Poppies Grow."

A man in a worn World War I uniform finds himself in Washington, D. C.  He has vivid memories of the horrors of the trenches, particularly of a friend being caught on the wire and begging to be put out of his misery by his comrades, but after that he has no memories--he doesn't even know his own name!  He walks around, marveling at how fashion and technology have changed, contrasting the public's attitude about the current war with the war in which he served.  He feels an urge to do something, as if he is on a mission, but he doesn't know what that mission could be.

He goes to a restaurant and meets an attractive young woman who is kind to him.  Then he wanders around town, trying to join up to fight again, but he is rejected because the doctor who gives him his physical can't find any pulse or heartbeat.  Our hero realizes he is dead, a ghost or an animated corpse or something; he can make contact with physical objects and even eat, but doesn't actually need to eat or breathe.  He tries to get a job so he can free up another man to go fight but can't find one because he has no skills.  (This story has some plot holes like this--couldn't he get a job as a janitor or farmhand or something?)

The dead soldier reads a newspaper editorial that argues the US shouldn't sink its resources into an offensive because the British don't deserve our help and we need to conserve our men and material to defend ourselves from the god damned.  The soldier, who has only been in the 1940s one day but already has strong opinions about foreign policy barges into the newspaper office to curse out the writer of this editorial.  Then it is back to wandering the streets.  Our guy finds himself near the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier.

The young woman finds him; she has with her a general (she has friends in high places.)  She shows our guy a newspaper--the writer whom he confronted has changed his tune, writing an editorial admitting he lied and the Communists are our buddies and anybody who says different is a traitor to America.  The general thinks the dead soldier came out of the Tomb (he can touch objects and people normally but also pass through stone, I guess--you know, whatever the plot requires) and also has the magic power to persuade anyone of anything.  The government can use him to travel the country and use his powers to persuade anybody who questions government policy to toe the line and obey Washington like a good American should.  Then the dead soldier and the young woman walk off together to begin a wonderful new life.

Each individual sentence of this story is well-written, but the story is long and slow and kind of boring and has those little plot holes, and of course I'm not crazy about the government using necromancy to get us all to mindlessly go along with whatever FDR and his lackeys want to do.  We're calling "Though Poppies Grow" barely acceptable.

One of Campbell's two big complaints about the earlier draft was that the dead soldier didn't actually much of a contribution to the war effort--apparently in that first version the dead soldier took the job of guarding the Tomb so that those soldiers guarding it could go to the front.  This is a good criticism with which del Rey agreed; a long story in which a miracle gives life to a dead man and the dead man goes on to do some penny ante thing is pretty lame.  And in fact the story still mostly consists of the main character being a sort of spectator who does little purposeful but is instead pushed around by other people and forces.  Campbell's other significant criticism was that readers would find an implied sexual liaison between a living human being and some kind of animated corpse "horrible."  Del Rey disagreed and while he dutifully made this implication a little less in-your-face in this version, it is still there.

What about del Rey's suspicion that people in 1975 wouldn't "react properly" to "Though Poppies Grow"?  Well, the story is very patriotic, and very pro-government, and by 1975 the leftist intelligentsia had taken over all the cultural institutions but hadn't yet captured every level of government, so the loudest segments of the educated public in 1975 would no doubt see a patriotic story which praised government policy as totally square if not ridiculous and disgusting, especially a story focused on foreign policy, seeing as the US government's foreign policy for the last few decades had revolved around trying, however incompetently, to obstruct the operations of the left-wing intellectuals' heroes like Che Guevara, Ho Chi Minh and Mao Zedong.  So, yeah, I can see del Rey assuming "Though Poppies Grow" might not receive a warm reception in 1975.

This mediocre story guaranteed to piss most people off with its flag-waving, or its sympathy for the USSR, or its glorification of the stifling of dissent, or its necrophilia has not been reprinted very often, though you can find it in the 2010 NESFA collection Robots and Magic.

Incidentally, this is the last story in the first part of The Early del Rey, and in the first volume of the two volume paperback publication of the collection.  This part of the book ends with a discussion of the story "Nerves," a piece which is well-regarded but which I didn't like when I read it years ago.             

"Lunar Landing" (1942)

As Part Two of Early del Rey begins, the author tells us Campbell had acquired a painting of a rocket sitting on the moon with the sun and Earth in the sky above and suggested del Rey write a story based upon it; "Lunar Landing" is that story. 

Our protagonist Grey is a somewhat unusual character, 80 lbs and 4' 10", suffering amnesia so he doesn't know who his family is.  He calls himself Grey because his hair and eyes are grey--even his skin has a grey look to it.  After waking memoryless,  and learning how to talk and read again, Grey, a man with a mechanical bent, worked in an aircraft factory and then became a skilled pilot.  When the first rocket to the moon, piloted by a Swanson, sent out a distress signal after a crash landing on Luna, Grey was chosen to pilot the rescue rocket, partly because he is so small he wouldn't add much weight to the rocket payload.

Part I of this longish (35 pages in The Early del Rey) story covers the trip to Luna and includes character backgrounds and a lot of banter among the crew that is characterized by sexual tension--there is a lot of cigarette smoking, for one thing (there was a lot of cigarette smoking with an erotic undertone in "Though Poppies Grow" as well), and when the rocket motors start malfunctioning the co-pilot, a red-headed young woman, in her fear, embraces Grey even though they have a very combative relationship.  There is another such odd couple among the crew who have a simmering inchoate sexual relationship.

Part II is on Luna after the crashlanding of Grey's rocket--these rockets seem to have a flaw that was not recognized on Earth.  The man who designed the vessels is among the crew on this ship, and this guy also has an acrimonious relationship with Grey.  

One of the distracting artistic choices del Rey makes in "Lunar Landing" is having the mysterious private entity who is sending these rockets to Luna fail to establish a chain-of-command or hierarchy among the crew of the ships--nobody aboard is formally recognized as captain and so there is a power struggle, with Grey coming out on top.  Adventure stories often feature these sorts of contests for authority, but it seems ridiculous to send a rocket to the moon--ostensibly only the second ever--without a designated captain.

Grey leads the majority of the crew (the designer stays behind to examine the engine) across the lunar surface towards what they think is the wreck of the first expedition.  The explorers discover native flora and fauna, and there are hints in the text that Grey, and/or other Earthers, have been to the moon before.  Sure enough, the rescue party finds not Swanson's wrecked ship but a third space ship!  An old woman among the crew, Alice Benson, tells the story of how she worked on this ship thirty years ago and has kept it a secret all these years; it was flown to Luna by her husband Bill.  It turns out she is the owner of the mysterious company organizing these expeditions.  The party returns to their ship only to find the designer has vanished.

Part III introduces a new conflict among the crew--Grey and Mrs. Benson are devoted to space travel out of a sense of romance, but another member of the crew is interested in exploring Luna in order to make money, and is even planning on exploiting the (as yet undiscovered) intelligent natives.  Grey and the redhead share their first kiss, and immediately afterwards share a cigarette.  From the nose of the rocket somebody, finally, spots Swanson's ship, and the sympathetic characters head for it, leaving the nasty money-grubbing imperialist behind.

Besides hoping to fin Swanson and his crew alive, the astronauts had hoped to find spare parts for their own engines, and are disappointed to find that the Swanson ship's motor has been removed--there is also no sign of Swanson, though the log describes the death of one of his two comrades and the disappearance of the other.  (Grey finds two unused cartons of cigarettes, so the sortie is not a total loss.)  When Grey and company get back to their own ship they find the imperialist is missing and the designer is back, but in a deep sleep.  When briefly roused he can't remember anything that has happened since he started a nap back on Earth!           

In Part IV Grey investigates the thirty-year old ship Benson ship--its rocket motors have also been stolen.  Whoever kidnapped the imperialist brings him back--like the designer he is in a deep sleep.  Grey and the redhead go up to the nose of their ship to spend a lot of time flirting and talking about cigarettes, which I guess is the thing they have in common that builds a bond between them.  They also spot a hole in the side of a cliff, and go investigate it with Mrs. Benson, figuring it will lead to the lair of whoever has been kidnapping their colleagues and seizing their rocket motors.

In Part V all is revealed.  Bill Benson's ship thirty years ago was spotted from Mars and a team from the red planet came to help the guy.  The Martians are experts in psychology, and have scientifically categorized people into two types, the goody goody idealists and the practical types who exploit others, and they can tell what type you are via their technology.  The idealists on Mars are running a secret space program that the exploiters don't know about.  The Martian lunar expedition was happy to find that Bill Benson was an idealist.  Similarly, Swanson and the survivors of his crew are idealists.  The Martians found that the designer and the imperialist were exploiters, and so erased their memories and returned them.  Obviously Mrs. Benson and the redhead are idealists.  As for Grey, he is the artificially created half-son of Bill Benson, a feat of genetic engineering sent to Earth with no memory.

The Martians propose a conspiracy.  Swanson and Mrs. Benson will go to Earth and claim the moon is a death trap with no valuable resources.  Then they will secretly get rich by mining all the valuable minerals on the Moon.  With all this money they will secretly manipulate Earth society so only idealists will have influence--the Martian idealists will do the same on Mars.  Eventually exploiters will have no power on either world.  Grey and the redhead will manage human operations on Luna--the Earth will be told they are dead.  The last line of the story is more flirting centered on cigarettes.

In the autobiographical text del Rey tells us "Lunar Landing" was a rush job and it is not a smooth read; the plot is repetitive and contrived, with too many boring characters and with people and ideas sort of popping up in the middle of the story as if from out of nowhere.  I actually like all the science stuff, the descriptions of space flight and space suits and lunar life and so forth, but all that stuff is just window dressing.  The rank elitism of the plot resolution--we can scientifically distinguish good people from bad people and the good people are allowed to do whatever they want to the bad people--for their own good, of course!--while sort of common in SF is also sort of annoying, and I didn't appreciate the constant gushing about how awesome cigarettes are--is this space program sponsored by Lucky Strike?

"Lunar Landing" hasn't been reprinted outside of del Rey collections, and we're calling it barely acceptable.  For del Rey completists and tobacco enthusiasts only!  

"Fifth Freedom" (1943) 

Here we have another story inspired by America's involvement in the Second World War.  The title of "Though Poppies Grow" is lifted from the famous poem "In Flanders Fields," which is quoted in the story and expresses the story's theme that the dead want us to keep fighting the Hun.  "Fifth Freedom" of course refers to FDR's 1941 speech about four freedoms, but del Rey does not refer to it in the story--it was Campbell who titled the story. 

It is the near future, and Germany is trying to conquer Europe yet again!  American opinion is galvanized into support for the war and there is a broad-based draft and the government seizes control of the economy.  Our protagonist is a conscientious objector and refuses to fight.  This is a science fiction story, so he has no religious rationale for his dissent--he just thinks war is bad!  His father disowns him.  The government sends him to a labor camp where the other laborers shun him--they are here because they are old or crippled or whatever--they are fully behind the war effort!  

Our sensitive hero is an amateur violinist, and on his off hours climbs a hill overlooking the labor camp to scrape away at his fiddle.  On the other side of the hill is a women's labor camp; there is a pretty girl over there, also on break, and the conscientious objector enjoys seeing her and imagining she can hear his music.  One day she actually comes up the hill to join him--she is also a music lover!  It's a love connection!

Our guy makes a friend in the labor camp, a cripple who is nonetheless a good fighter who helps protect our musician from a bully.  Life is looking up!  A girl and a friend!  The Air Force sends a representative to the camp to talk to the musician, who, it turns out, is also an expert pilot--his family was wealthy enough that he could afford a civilian model of one of the new rocket planes and he has like one thousand hours of flight time!  Uncle Sam would love to strap him into a USAAF rocket plane so he can drop bombs on Deutschland like a good American boy should!  Of course, our guy isn't interested in signing up, even after the Germans blow up New York and then Chicago with their radiation bombs!

The violinist, his friend the cripple and the girl are on that hill when the krauts bomb their labor camps.  The girl gets radiation sickness and dies, and, finally, the protagonist decides to enlist with the flyboys, though only after he reflects that America is better than Germany because in Germany the government forces people to fight and in the US the government just tries really really hard to persuade you to fight.

The ideological content and character relationships of "Fifth Freedom" are not very impressive, and the science fiction content is limited, though del Rey brags in the autobiographical section that follows that he is one of the first to stress the danger of radiation from atomic bombs, not just the game-changing volume of blast of such weapons.  Another barely acceptable story.      

**********

Three weak stories in a row.  In fairness to del Rey, he tells us early on in Early del Rey that this volume is going to consist of stories not previously collected, so we have to expect the content of the book to be below his average.  The main draw of Early del Rey's 400 pages is perhaps his reminiscences of his relationship with Campbell and his insights into the SF world of the '30s and '40s.  Probably when I have finished with this book I will read some collections of his more acclaimed work.

Wednesday, September 25, 2024

2015 weird madness from A D Foster, W F Nolan, N Kilpatrick and S R Tem

Let's crack open my copy of 2015's The Madness of Cthulhu: Volume Two and read four more 21st-century stories inspired by H. P. Lovecraft that bear the S. T. Joshi seal of approval.

"The Door Beneath" by Alan Dean Foster

Foster's name feels very familiar even though I have read very little of his work during the period of this blog's life; Foster penned the first two Star Wars novels and the Black Hole novelization and I think a lot of his books were at the public library when I was a kid (I was born in 1971 so books like For Love of Mother-Not and Spellsinger would have been in hardcover at the library when I was in my early teens.)  A few years ago I read his story "With Friends Like These..." and thought it OK.  And I think "The Door Beneath" is similarly OK, maybe a little worse than OK, a standard issue science fiction action story with a little Yog-Sothery sprinkled on it.

Our protagonist is the head of safety at an important Soviet installation, the nature of which is kept from us readers.  A big wig accompanied by KGB brutes gives our guy a tour of a secret installation under the main installation.  Down there we find a huge subterranean chamber where toil an army of scientists and technicians on two unusual objects of tremendous size, a towering hunk of what looks like organic matter bigger than a whale and a bizarre contraption like an abstract sculpture above which shimmers a sort of black sphere.  These things were discovered in Antarctica, we learn.  As our main characters watch, the white lab coat crew pumps a bazillion gigajoules of electricity into the organic mass and it quivers to life, scores of eyes and pseudopods ending in toothy mouths emerging.  And then they see something scary in the black sphere--the sphere, they realize, is a portal to some other world and genocidal monsters are going to come out of it.  Our hero hurries upstairs as the monster (eventually Foster just tells us it is a shoggoth) devours his comrades behind him.  Upstairs he somehow convinces his colleagues to blow up the public installation they are standing in, which we learn is the Chernobyl nuclear reactor, killing the shoggoth and closing the portal, and thus saving the world.

A simplistic and plodding story in which the characters don't act in ways that are very convincing and which lacks anything like a Lovecraftian tone or spirit and also fails to supply anything engaging on its own terms, "The Door Beneath" is a barely acceptable filler story, with its focus on nuclear power more like a mediocre story from Astounding than something from Weird Tales.  (Compare "The Door Beneath" to two stories we read last time from Volume 1 of Madness of Cthulhu--Robert Silverberg's "Diana of the Hundred Breasts," which added good human drama to stereotypical Lovecraftian commonplaces and Darrel Schweitzer's "Warm" which embraced Lovecraftianism wholeheartedly and achieved a real Lovecraftian tone and atmosphere.)  Either go all the way with the weird horror goop or give us something new--and good--which integrates some Lovecraftian themes or images; don't give us lowest common denominator science fiction with the most obvious and banal and superficial Lovecraft dressing spritzed on it.

"The Door Beneath" would be reprinted in 2019 in the Foster collection The Taste of Different Dimensions.

"Dead Man Walking" by William F. Nolan

Oy.  I compared Foster's story to a below-average specimen from Astounding, but Nolan's is even less Lovecraftian and even less entertaining--"Dead Man Walking" is like a 1970s TV movie written by somebody influenced by somebody who was influenced by what he heard about Dashiell Hammett.  I think "Dead Man Walking" may be an unfunny spoof of such TV fare, or perhaps was even based on some script Nolan sketched out that he was unable to sell.  Thumbs down!

A writer guy lives in L.A.  (I couldn't care less about L.A. and I am sick of always seeing it on screen or reading about it or hearing people talk about it.  Who the hell still cares about In and Out Burger and Rodeo Drive and Sepulvedra or whatever the hell it is?  Enough already.)  Writer guy is working on a nonfiction book about how the supernatural is a load of crap.  But then a hot chick whose husband, a sculptor, died, calls him up to ask for his help--she thinks her husband is alive and trying to kill her!

We spend like seventeen pages with the writer, the widow, and a gallery owner who is also some kind of medium or witch or something, Madame Jechiel.  Jechiel gave the sculptor a magic ring that allowed him to live forever if he cut a deal with monsters from another dimension--he had to make statues of the monsters and anoint them with human blood and then the aliens would inhabit and animate the statues and take over the Earth.  The writer and the woman outfight the sculptor and the aliens in a way that is not scary or exciting and is not convincing in the least.

This story is bad.  The characters lack personality and act in ways that are not believable, and Nolan writes in a lifeless barebones style that fails to make anything that happens compelling logically or emotionally--plot developments don't follow each other in a way that makes sense, but seem to exist to set up scenes that have the potential to be visually arresting while not requiring much trouble or expense to film.  "Dead Man Walking" is also stuffed with poorly delivered bargain basement jokes, like the writer not liking the nickname his editor has given him and trying to quit smoking and that sort of thing.  I kept flipping through pages to see how many were left, the way I used to look at the clock every thirty seconds at school, at my job in a machine shop, at my job in a department store, at my job at a book store, at my job in a government office, at my job in a warehouse....

So bad I am angry.  Joshi should have deep-sixed this rough draft. 

Looking at the records, it seems I have now read 10 stories by Nolan.  That's right, it is links time.

Title                                                    TLDR quote from my blog post on the story  

"And Miles to Go Before I Sleep"     "OK...a little sappy"
"He Kilt It With a Stick"                    "competent, but pedestrian" 
"Gorf! Gorf! Gorf!"                            "Fourteen pages of feeble jokes."
"Starblood"                                         "lacks any sort of character, feeling or plot"
"Papa's Planet"                                    "Acceptable, I guess."
"Lap of the Primitive"                         "Weak....Lame!"
"Toe to Tip, Tip to Toe,                       "A total waste of time."
"Dead Call"                                         "Acceptable."
"One of Those Days"                          "Total junk."
"Dead Man Walking"                          "So bad I am angry."

Never again, Stoker Lifetime Achievement Award and International Horror Guild Living Legend Award winner William F. Nolan, never again.

(UPDATE SEPTEMBER 29, 2024:  I didn't do a good job looking through the records because today I find I've also read a story by Nolan called "Jenny Among the Zeebs" and declared it "unfunny and nonsensical" and "Bad.")

"A Crazy Mistake" by Nancy Kilpatrick

I've never read anything by Kilpatrick before, though I've read stories in anthologies she has edited.  Kilpatrick has written a lot of fiction we might describe as niche, like novels about Jason Vorhees of Friday the 13th fame and pornographic novels about having sex with Dracula, Dorian Gray, Dr. Jekyll, or the Frankenstein monster.  I'm not going to judge; I'm as horny as the next guy and I have done things I might not brag about for money--I've worked in a government office, after all.

The narrator of "A Crazy Mistake" is a self-sacrificing woman who left her boyfriend, a student at Miskatonic U, so she wouldn't distract him from his studies and moved to L.A. (ugh) to work as a researcher for B-movies.  She helps schlock filmmakers by doing research on mythology and the supernatural, looking for ideas about mummies or vampires or whatever they can integrate into their bad movies.  She is hired to do research on Amazons and talks on the phone with her ex-boyfriend about them and that gets her interested in purported prehistoric matriarchal societies and those famous Paleolithic sculptures of obese women with beehive hair.  The narrator takes a trip back East to use the Miskatonic U. library to do deeper research, including reading a handwritten first-hand account of the expedition described in At The Mountains of Madness, and she comes to believe that space aliens, the Great Old Ones, created human life on Earth, starting with fat women with beehive heads and then breeding them with Neanderthals, more or less as a joke.  She compares this frivolous entertainment to the B-movies she has had a small part in creating--life is meaningless so intelligent beings, be they the Great Old Ones or their creations--us!--try to fill their empty lives with pointless entertainment.  She ends up insane, believing her body is changing, getting fat, like one of those prehistoric sculptures, because she stole and ate a piece of that manuscript upon which was a sketch of just such a sculpture seen by the explorer in the Antarctic.

"A Crazy Mistake" feels kind of long even though quite little happens; Kilpatrick devotes long passages to describing theories of prehistoric matriarchy and to summarizing At The Mountains of Madness.  But it is not terrible, and maybe will appeal to feminists (the characters use the word "patriarchal" totally unironically like a dozen times) and to goth kids who recognize that life is meaningless and everybody is psychologically damaged but don't keep this knowledge to themselves like the rest of us do.  (Kilpatrick is also author of 2004's The Goth Bible.)  We'll call "A Crazy Mistake" acceptable if forgettable.

I'm never going to read William F. Nolan again, but if I ever feel like reading about women having sex with animated corpses or demons, Kilpatrick is going to be my go-to, so you can look forward to that.

"Deep Fracture" by Steve Rasnic Tem

This is a pretty literary story, with descriptions of the sky, themes of the sadness of working class life and conventional sexual relationships (ignoring phone calls from your nagging wife while you are out running errands, getting the supplies you need to do the cosmetic home repairs she expects you to do after spending a tiring week at work), themes of decay and a recurring motif of lines--cracks, hair, wires, worms.  I think I can mildly recommend this one--it is certainly the best one we are reading today, Tem taking the task seriously (unlike Foster and Nolan who are phoning it in or making a joke of it) and pacing and structuring the story ably (unlike Kilpatrick.)  There are lots of Lovecraftian things going on, and the literary stuff doesn't get in the way of the weird horror elements--Tem's metaphors and descriptions are not too long or too opaque and they all work.

Tom and Walt live in an Appalachian coal town that recently has been afflicted with earthquakes, such that the roads and buildings--ugly stores, houses and strip malls--are crumbling.  Walt is the older man, a geologist, and he is tagging along as Tom drives all over town buying stuff so he can refurbish his and his wife's house--his wife keeps calling him on his cell phone.  Snow is threatening, and Tom is sort of looking forward to snow covering up the ugliness of his decaying town.

All through the story we get hints that suggest a Lovecraftian cataclysm is about to strike, an alien city and its monstrous inhabitants about to rise up under the town and, I guess, kill everybody.  The cold feels strange; Walt admits that his father retired from coal mining because he kept having dreams of an alien city beneath the mines, then Walt shows Tom a spire or some such architectural fragment his father found in the mines which has indecipherable writing inscribed on it; wife calls up to say the contractors hired to clear their sewer line have found it is clogged with "lines" like hair and worms.

Nolan, Kilpatrick and Tem completists are going to have to buy a copy of The Madness of Cthulhu: Volume Two because "Dead Man Walking," "A Crazy Mistake," and "Deep Fracture" have not been reprinted elsewhere, though Tem's story deserves to be.

**********

One good story, two acceptable, and one bad?  A big step down from our last episode.  Well, sometimes you get the shoggoth, and sometimes the shoggoth gets you.

It's back to the World War II era next time here at MPorcius Fiction Log; see you there, fellow investigators of the astounding and the unknown.

Tuesday, September 24, 2024

Yog-Sothery madness from R Silverberg, M Tem and D Schweitzer

If you are interested in vintage SF and by some black twist of fate find yourself in the region of Hagerstown, MD, you should take the time to visit the antique stores on Route 40, because at Memory Lane Antiques, Antiques Crossroads and Beaver Creek Antique Market a wealth of old genre paperbacks, magazines and comic books as well as all manner of related material is on offer, much of it at bargain prices.  Recently at Antiques Crossroads I purchased for five dollars each paperback copies of The Madness of Cthulhu Volumes I (2014) and II (2015), anthologies of new stories edited by S. T. Joshi that (according to the back cover, at least) were inspired by At the Mountains of Madness, one of H. P. Lovecraft's most famous productions.  These books, once in the library of a John Johnson of Darrington, Washington, are in quite good shape--they look unread, though tick marks next to the titles of the stories on the contents page of the first volume suggest he did read them--so thanks to Mr. Johnson for taking good care of them.  Produced by Titan Books, the books look great, with nice fonts and cool cover images by John Jude Palencar, details from his Terror in A.D. 1000.

In a departure from normal MPorcius practice, let's take a look at Volume I and read some stories written in the last ten or twelve years.

"Diana of the Hundred Breasts" by Robert Silverberg (1996)

Contrary to what I just said, here is a reprinted story from 1996.  Consider this a plot twist.  (Madness of Cthulhu reprints two stories by Grand Masters of Science Fiction, this one and Arthur C. Clarke's "At the Mountains of Murkiness," which I am skipping because I assume it is a joke story.)  "Diana of the Hundred Breasts" debuted in Realms of Fantasy alongside a story by Tanith Lee and articles about Czech fantastic art and literature and about the illustrations on game cards.  The back cover of The Madness of Cthulhu suggests "Diana of the Hundred Breasts" is "rare" and "lost," but it was in fact reprinted in a Silverberg collection and two anthologies before Madness of Cthulhu was released: Volume Nine of The Collected Robert Silverberg, Ellen Datlow and Terri Windling's tenth Year's Best Fantasy and Horror and Nancy Kilpatrick and Thomas S. Roche's 2000 anthology Graven Images.  

"Diana of the Hundred Breasts" is a good story, with effective fantastic elements and engaging human elements.  Our narrator is a wealthy slacker who just travels around for fun, spending a lot of time on the Mediterranean visiting ancient sites.  He has a somewhat difficult relationship with his brother, a leading archaeologist; big bro is a genius with exceptional good looks who can also be a cruel and arrogant jerk.  For the first time in a few years these brothers hook up at an archeological site in Turkey.  They meet a fellow American, a Protestant minister from the Midwest who is a widower, and the archaeologist, an atheist who has contempt for religion and, as we expect of a college professor, is confident religion is just a scam used by elites to control the masses, sort of needles this guy, poking fun at Christianity, suggesting it is no better or different than paganism.  But the narrator suspects the cleric may have his brother's number--the minister believes the archaeologist, though gifted and privileged in so many ways, is unhappy because he is empty inside due to a lack of belief in anything.

At the site, the two brothers accidentally set free a space monster which is, perhaps, the source material of the famous image of Diana of Epheseus, and the experience has a profound effect on the archaeologist, shaking his cynical rationalist view of the universe--maybe there is more to the universe than the eye can see.

The people feel real and the images of the ruins and of the monster that may well have been a goddess to the ancient Greeks are vivid--thumbs up for "Diana of the Hundred Breasts!"  

"Cantata" by Melanie Tem (2014)

I think I've read four stories by Melanie Tem, "The Country of the Blind," "The Marriage" (with Steve Rasnic Tem), "Iced In," and "Lunch at Charon's," and liked them all, so it makes sense to read this one.  "Cantata" would be reprinted in the Tem collection Singularity and Other Stories.

"Cantata" is OK; I'm not thrilled by it.

A woman who has a mental condition called "amusia" or "amusica" is part of a scientific team on an alien planet or maybe just a remote previously unexplored part of Earth.  This site is home to intelligent but primitive humanoid natives, the survivors of a more advanced civilization that was destroyed by legendary enemies; these survivors may perhaps share an ancestor with us normal humans.  (These elements of course remind us of Lovecraft, whose work is full of degenerate races and old ruins and vague memories of past apocalyptic wars and hints that the human race is the product of genetic engineering by aliens.)  People with amusia cannot understand or enjoy music, and our heroine actually hates music.  The lost tribe she is working among has no music, no knowledge of music, music having been lost in that cataclysmic war thousands of years past.  But while here on the expedition she has begun hearing music, music nobody else hears, and it is driving her insane--the sounds cause her to itch, and she scratches so vigorously that she penetrates her skin, inflicting upon herself bloody wounds.  Eventually the natives rediscover music and begin humming and our heroine scratches herself so ferociously that she cuts her own throat with her nails and even penetrates her own skull and damages her own brain.

"Cantata" is subtle and literary as well as disgusting in its depiction of injuries, so shares a lot with the other stories by Tem I have read, but I somehow am not enjoying it as much as those others.  If I had to guess I'd say it is because the main character doesn't show agency--in the other Tem stories I praised so much, characters demonstrated evil or self-destructiveness through their actions, which excites powerful emotions in the reader and raises issues of morality, while here in this story the protagonist is primarily a victim of unknowable forces who is defined by an unalterable innate characteristic.  Stories about those who act are inherently more engaging than stories about those who are acted upon, and narratives about people defined by what they do more compelling than those about people defined by inherited identities.      

"The Warm" by Darrell Schweitzer (2014)

I liked Schweitzer's novel The Shattered Goddess and his stories "Going to Ground," and "Malevendra's Pool," so let's give this story a try.  In 2015 "The Warm" would reappear in the Schweitzer collection Awaiting Strange Gods.

Once at a book store I saw that someone had written a novel in which the wife of Captain Ahab of Moby Dick fame was the main character, and I recently heard that someone wrote a novel in which Julia of 1984 was the main character.  Part of the excitement of such derivate productions is that they are works by and about women, whom we are told are "marginalized."  Well, who could be more marginalized than a monster who lives in an underground labyrinth that almost no surface dwellers even know exist?  "The Warm" is based on Lovecraft's famous tale "Pickman's Model" and its narrator is the ghoul whom Pickman induced to serve as an inspiration for his macabre art.

Schweitzer does a good job of depicting the alien world beneath our feet and the lives of the monsters down there, and the psychology of a man who joined the ghoul population but is the least of their horrible number, and, through his contact with Pickman, begins to regain his humanity at the same time Pickman is losing his!  The pacing and images of the story are quite good, and I liked the twist ending.  Thumbs up!  

**********

This was an enjoyable exercise, so let's keep it up--we'll read four stories from the second volume of The Madness of Cthulhu in our next episode.

Monday, September 23, 2024

The Unfrozen by Ernst Dreyfuss

These people were our enemies.  Two of us against thousands, perhaps hundreds of thousands of superior, mechanically ultrasophisticated human beings.  Judging by their everyday gadgets, their weaponry must have been something awesome.  They distrusted us because we were different from them, primitive to their way of looking at life.  They were desireless, while we looked at life as a God-given gift to enjoy.  We were in a bottomless pit.  Was there really a way to get out of it?

Over a year ago at an antique mall I bought a copy of 1970's The Unfrozen because it had a Jeff Jones cover.  In a recent gesture towards organizing the shelves of the MPorcius Library, I came upon this 158-page paperback and thought I might read it, see what it is all about.  The Science Fiction Encyclopedia suggests there is a mystery as to who the author, who only has this single work listed at isfdb, really is.  Well, I like getting direct first-hand knowledge of these oddities, so let's dig in.

Our narrator, Neal McDavid, is an intern in Houston, in 1969.  His official work is in the development of heart transplantation, but he is also interested in life extension and especially cryogenics.  His girlfriend is a beautiful blonde nurse, Marya Svenson, a Swedish immigrant.  We get some soap opera stuff in the first two chapters of this 29-chapter novel as we witness the start of this couple's relationship and their disputes over birth control and abortion--Marya is Catholic and refuses to use a condom when they have sex and when she gets pregnant she rejects Neal's suggestion she have an abortion.  She wants to get married but he insists they wait a year, until he has finished his internship.  She runs off and gets severely injured in a car wreck that it is hinted is a suicide attempt.  

When Marya shows up at the hospital where Neal is interning and is found to be braindead, the staff plans to carve her up so her organs can be used in transplants, but Neal (who, as an intern, has more authority than I would have thought) has her frozen intact, and then freezes himself--he has realized he can't live without Marya and is willing to risk the freezing process rather than face the possibility his beloved won't be revived until after he has grown old or died.  Somewhat humorously, the freezing process does not involve drugs or machinery--Neal just uses buckets of ice and lays down next to his clinically dead girlfriend.  There are a few scenes like this that make you wonder if The Unfrozen is a goofy satire.

Neal wakes up in the future, in a huge transparent antiseptic space station.  The people here are all thin, never blink, and have a skin color like coffee with milk, apparently the product of centuries of race-mixing.  This future nation consists of a bunch of space stations--this is the hospital station.  The people have numbers instead of names, call each other "comrade," and have no emotion and make no provisions for privacy.  Computers and robots do all the surgery, and in minutes have fixed Marya's head injury with artificial spare parts; most of the people Neal sees have bodies largely consisting of such spare parts, the availability of which has rendered these future people almost immortal.  The space people don't even eat or defecate--on a regular schedule a computer pumps them intravenously full of a perfect mix of nutrients and calories.  The future people have no knowledge of sex or love--new comrades are produced in a test tube when needed and they are castrated.  When a sleeping Neal has a wet dream the future people are disgusted and decide to castrate Neal and Marya.

Neal figures out a way for he and Marya to escape sterilization.  The space station civilization is in trouble.  The food they all receive intravenously is made from coal, and in a century or so their supply will run out.  Neal offers to go down to Earth to collect more coal--the unblinking future people are unable to accomplish any work down there because the artificial parts that compose most of their bodies aren't suited to the current Earth climate, which is extremely cold, nor to operation at 1 gee--there is no gravity on the space stations and the space comrades spend centuries under weightless conditions.

As the middle third of The Unfrozen begins Neal and Marya meet the president of this post-Earth civilization, the oldest man alive, the only living person (besides Neal and Marya) who was born on Earth--this guy has dark skin--Neal compares his complexion to that of a "mulatto"--and he even blinks.  The Prez gives our heroes a history lesson about the end of life on Earth in 2204, over 500 years ago--he and a few Americans were in orbit at the time of the nuclear war started by the United States of Africa and their ally China against the United States of America and the USSR, and the frozen Neal and Marya were with them.  Over the last five centuries the survivors have built the current space-based society, a society with no desire, no privacy, no racism, no theft or war.  Also, as they begin to run out of coal, laws against wasting energy by speaking unnecessarily.

It takes a while, but Neal finally convinces the government to send our heroes to Earth along with the regular monthly relief team of scientists that man the research station there--the space station people can only stand being on the surface for thirty days, and they never leave the building, just sit in chairs and study the surface with telescopes.  The research center turns out to have been built into Hitler's Berlin bunker, one of the few buildings to survive the atomic war, and Neal and Marya sleep in a bed with "Eva Braun" inscribed on the headboard.  I guess this is part of the satire, the suggestion that Hitler is representative of the Earthbound human race.   

The scientists in the bunker expand on the history lesson the Prez gave our heroes.  In the 21st century the major nations dug up such a volume of natural resources to fuel the space race that the Earth became a hollow shell and earthquakes resulted that killed millions.  The various blocs competed ruthlessly for what little resources were left.  The Chinese-led bloc was developing a superweapon that threatened to give them control of the Earth, so the Western and Westernized states allied with the Soviet Union to launch a preemptive strike that obliterated the Chinese-led bloc.  This left only the US-USSR alliance and a united Africa to contend for the rulership of the world.  The global north was on the brink of achieving the ability to colonize Mars when the Africans, stung by white racism, decided to launch all their nuclear weapons at the white and white-adjacent countries, causing so much destruction that the Earth's orbit was altered, leading to the decrease in temperature and death of every human on the planet.  Sure enough, when Neal and Marya put on their therma suits and oxygen tanks and explore the ruins of Berlin they find frozen corpses among the wreckage.  (These peeps are too irradiated to be revived the way our 20th-century heroes were.)

As the final third of the novel begins Neal and Marya commit suicide--this future world is no place to live in, no place to bring up a child!  They walk out into the freezing cold, oxygen-deficient air of post-holocaust Earth and die, only to be revived by the space people, good as new.  After this caper, the tone of the novel changes; maybe we are supposed to be reminded of how the death and rebirth of Jesus led to a new hopeful era of human life or something.  Whereas earlier, the Earthers considered the space people a bunch of cold mechanical drones living under a tyranny, and the space people considered our heroes dangerous because they were driven by emotion and constituted the sort of people who caused the Earth-ruining nuclear war, after the suicide episode Neal and Marya eagerly pledge allegiance to the space society and become full comrades (they now love Big Brother!) and the space people spare no expense in training and equipping the Earthers so they can survive on Mars, the world they will colonize and from which extract the essential coal.  It is not uncommon in SF novels for the protagonist to switch sides as he realizes the superiority of the alien or rebel society, but here in The Unfrozen Neal's change of attitude seems to come out of nowhere.

Mars in this book has a rich native ecosystem, including extensive deposits of coal and a race of intelligent, though culturally and technologically primitive, natives.  When Earth's orbit was altered, so was that of Mars, and the red planet is now as close to the sun as was Terra and considerably warmer than previously.  The space people train Neal and Marya in the approved technique of dealing with the native life--by projecting thought waves that transmit love!  If the Martian birds and cows know Neal and Marya love them, they will eagerly give up their eggs and milk.  (The space people refuse N & M permission to hunt animals for food.)  And if the intelligent Martians know Neal and Marya love them, they will not attack them.  This whole idea made me groan, because, at the start of the novel, space people were portrayed as emotionless and were even asking Neal to explain what love is to them, and now we are supposed to believe their whole society is based on love and they have advanced psychic techniques to express emotion?  This is a blunder; did Dreyfuss start this novel planning to make the space society a dystopia, and then past the halfway point decide to make it a utopia, and forget to revise the beginning?

Mars is just like Earth, with green grass and forests of pine trees and moss-covered rock, but better--the animals are larger and the cows and chickens produce a prodigious supply of milk and eggs.  Neal and Marya begin a happy fulfilling life on their little Martian farm, which they contrast with their horrible 20th-century lives of the "dog-eat-dog" "rat race," when they had to fight traffic and pay bills.  The novel's climax comes when Marya gives birth to the child conceived back in the 20th century--while she is in labor the Martians arrive, hostile, but Neal and Marya project friendship waves at them and prevent a massacre.

The last dozen or so pages of the novel take place five years on, when our heroes have produced five children who will give birth to the new human race (Neal says "Never mind the incest angle") that will live in harmony, unlike the humanity of Earth which was constantly killing for food and (Neal suggests here at the end of the novel) over sexual frustration.  Neal has also, somehow, built freezers, refrigerators, and a laboratory.  The Martians are the humans' friends and dozens of them work the fields in exchange for food.  Neal figures out why the native Martians are a dying race--they don't get sexually aroused when it is warm, so Neal, who has already revitalized the human race, is going to revitalize the Martian race by setting up air-conditioned buildings in which the Martians can have sex.  (Dreyfuss--and his editors at Tower--commit another blunder here: we are told Neal locks up the fridge so the natives can't see he has been dissecting a dead Martian, and three pages later that he left the fridge door open and it is that cool air which facilitated amorousness among some Martians cleaning the lab.)  

The novel ends with Neal and Marya expressing the belief that everything has happened according to God's plan, and with the implication that the novel's main point is to vindicate authority--the authority of God over the universe has led to a happy life for humans and Martians on Mars, the authority of the space state ended racism and war, and the authority of Neal (who is explicitly likened to God) over the Martians is going to save the native people of the fourth (now third) planet from extinction.

The Unfrozen has a lot of problems but I am feeling generous; since I didn't find it to be terribly laborious or annoying, and there are some glimmers of interest and originality here and there, we'll say it is barely acceptable.  The novel is perhaps an unusual specimen in that it rags on and on about how people are jerks--racist and bellicose--like so much SF does but has a sympathetic view of religion and argues that God is real when most SF stories consider religion a plague.  Potentially interesting issues like religion, racism, sexual dysfunction and the social and psychological drawbacks of immortality are treated in a superficial way, but at least they are there--this isn't a mediocre novel that tries to entertain you with sex and violence, like one of the many Conan pastiches, but a novel in which the author is ambitious and is trying to lay his philosophy on you and tell you what society should be like but he doesn't do a good job of it.  Dreyfuss' style is not great but I suppose it gets the job done, despite some odd tics, like how some words particular to the space society always appear in all caps.  The plot has numerous holes and incongruities (e. g., this super high tech society can't construct remote-controlled robots to mine coal on Mars or Earth?--they already have autonomous robots who can do brain surgery and heart, lung and liver transplants!; every plant and animal on Mars is just like one native to Earth, except the people, who are monsters covered in quills or spines) and the transitions from bitter suspicion between Earthers and spacers to committed solidarity, and from "this is a sterile and emotionless totalitarian state" to "this is a utopia of brotherhood" are poorly handled.  On the plus side, Neal's relationship with Marya and his evolution from abortion-advocating skeptic to devoted husband and father sort of work, and some elements of life in zero gee in the space station society are interesting and feel original.

This unlovely mess has actually been reprinted--in translation into Norwegian with a good cover that doesn't suit the contents depicting an old guy and a young beauty facing some kind of trouble, maybe an aircraft, maybe a really tall person.

Saturday, September 21, 2024

Henry S. Whitehead: "The Shadows," "The Fireplace," and "The Passing of a God"

We recently read a story by Frank Belknap Long recommended by New Jersey native Robert Weinberg, author of The Weird Tales Story (1977) and Horror of the 20th Century: An Illustrated History (1999).  Weinberg, in those books, praises Henry S. Whitehead, another man who hails from the greatest state in the Union, but one who spent much of his life in the Caribbean.  Whitehead published quite a volume of stories in Weird Tales, and Weinberg picks out three for particular praise: "The Shadows," "The Fireplace," and "The Passing of a God."  Today, through the magic of the internet archive, we'll read them and assess whether Whitehead, whom Weinberg deemed in 1999 to be a "neglected writer," deserves to be better known today.

I may be reading these stories in Weird Tales, but all three can be found in the 1944 Arkham House hardcover collection Jumbee and Other Uncanny Tales and its British 1974 edition, put out by Neville Spearman.  For paperback publication our tea-guzzling pals over in the green and pleasant land split Jumbee and Other Uncanny Tales into two volumes; "The Passing of a God" and "The Shadows" appear in the first volume, Jumbee and Other Voodoo Tales, while "The Fireplace" is printed in the second, The Black Beast and Other Voodoo Tales. 

"The Shadows" (1927)

This is a pretty effective story with a smooth understated style with quite a bit of local color about life in the West Indies for American and European residents.  Our wealthy narrator, Stewart, an American, lives on a West Indian island in the house formerly occupied by an elderly Irish colonist, Morris, who died under mysterious circumstances.  Stewart begins to experience a bizarre phenomena--when he turns off the light in his bedroom he can dimly see shadowy or ghostly images of different furniture than his own--presumably this is what the room looked like when Morris lived there.  Each night, the images are sharper, clearer, and eventually Stewart can see Morris's furniture--in the dark--as clearly as he can see his own furniture in the light.  Eventually he can see the image of Morris himself in the process of retiring for the night.

The second part of the story describes the narrator's detective work as he travels around the island talking to people and learning about his predecessor's strange life and mysterious death.  It seems that, before moving to this island, Morris had truck with non-whites on another island and with one or more "jumbees;" "jumbee," a word I haven't encountered before, is apparently a term used in the West Indies to refer to a broad class of evil entities--spirits or ghosts or demons or whatever.  People are reluctant to give our hero much information on Morris, and after, on a significant date, the narrator witnesses Morris's horrible death in the very room in which Stewart now sleeps, Stewart shocks his fellow expatriates with a dramatic revelation of his knowledge.

One might say this story moves slowly, but the style and images are good enough that it never becomes tiresome or boring.  I enjoyed "The Shadows," and I think other Lovecraft fans might enjoy it as well, even though it is more light-hearted and the stakes feel much lower than in a Lovecraft story (Stewart is never in any kind of danger and is never really scared, being buoyed by his Christian faith), if only because it includes a pretty cool monster.

"The Shadows" after its debut in Weird Tales has been reprinted by such editors as August Derleth and Donald Wollheim as well as in Whitehead collections; in 2006 "The Shadows," as well as "The Passing of a God" and two additional Whitehead stories, was included in an anthology of supernatural stories written "in the Christian tradition"--Whitehead was an Episcopal minister.


"The Fireplace" (1925)

This is an OK ghost and murder story; while well-written, I am afraid there are too many nagging issues with the plot and structure of "The Fireplace" for me to call it good.  Also, its locale is the American South, and the local color elements are not as interesting or effective as the West Indies stuff in "The Shadows."

The first little section of the story tells us that in 1922 a hotel in Mississippi burned down, killing four men prominent in politics and the law in MS, Georgia and Tennessee.  Then we flash back a decade to the hotel and a young lawyer who is staying in the same room in which the four victims of the future fire will perish.  The lawyer is surprised when a man inexplicably appears in the room--this man turns out to be a ghost.  The ghost explains that sixteen years earlier he was murdered in this very room during a poker game, and the four men with whom he was playing--one of them his murderer--cut up his body and burned it in the fireplace and then hid his unburnable effects--cufflinks and such--under the floorboards.  The ghost directs the lawyer to where these unburnables are concealed, proving his story true, and gets the lawyer to promise to pursue justice on the killer and his three accomplices.  

The lawyer gets so busy with his career that he doesn't do anything to right the wrong supernaturally revealed to him and some time later he ends up in that hotel room again and he is found dead, strangled, his head in the fireplace.

On a sentence by sentence and paragraph by paragraph basis this story is well-written and it is never boring.  However, there are problems with the plot and with some of Whitehead's narrative choices.  I don't think you could really obliterate an adult human's bones in a 19th-century open fireplace, for one thing.  Another problem is that we are to believe that the ghost strangled the lawyer who failed to help him, but earlier in the story the ghost said that he could only interact with the material world with great effort--"Managing to knock at the door took it out of me, rather...."  Wouldn't strangling a healthy man and moving his body dramatically into the fireplace be far more strenuous an activity than knocking at a door?  Another issue is that we don't get a scene of the ghost destroying the four men--how did he do it?  I think we also have to wonder if four murderers would meet on the anniversary of their crime in the very spot in which they committed their crime (as in "The Shadows," dates and places are very significant in "The Fireplace," ghosts being very much connected to particular rooms and dates.)  

Acceptable.  "The Fireplace" was reprinted in Weird Tales in 1935 and since then in numerous anthologies of ghost stories, Perturbed Spirits (1954 hardcover, 1958 paperback) edited by R. C. Bull and Helen Hoke's Ghosts and Ghastlies (1976) among them.


"The Passing of a God" (1931)

Farnsworth Wright reprinted "The Passing of a God" in Weird Tales in 1938 after its debut in the Unique Magazine seven years earlier, and Dorothy McIlwraith reprinted it in one of the last issues of the first run of WT in 1954.  In addition, the story has reappeared in several anthologies, including a Peter Haining volume of stories from WT and the aforementioned book of ghost stories "in the Christian tradition," Shadows from a Veiled Creation.  

Our narrator in "The Passing of a God" is an American living in the Virgin Islands and the story consists of his conversation with a Dr. Pelletier about a patient Pelletier treated while he was in Haiti, an American named Carswell.  We learn the crazy life story of Carswell, presented somewhat out of chronological order so as to offer surprises to the reader.  I'll just summarize the Carswell saga chronologically here. 

Carswell, a man in his thirties, left New York when he learned he had a sort of tumor, about the size of a man's head, in his abdomen and was told he had only a year or so to live.  He went to Haiti and made a sizable living shooting and drying ducks for export to the Chinatowns of New York and San Francisco.  His tumor grew only slowly, and he survived year after year, putting together a nice house and becoming an integral part of the local black community; Carswell became very familiar with voodoo, and when Pelletier met him Carswell probably knew more about voodoo than any other white man.

Seven years after his arrival in Haiti, Carswell collapsed while walking home and woke up to find himself seated on a chair, surrounded by hundreds of blacks who were kneeling before him; Carswell's hands were weighed down with over one hundred rings and his neck strained under the weight of innumerable necklaces.  Carswell recognized the phenomena of which he was the center.  In Haiti, when a person, usually an elderly individual or someone mentally ill or developmentally disabled, as we now put it, throws a fit or goes visibly insane, the natives think he is possessed by a god and worship him; when he recovers his senses they feel the god has left and cease their worship.  Carswell assured the "negroes" he was fine now, and they had no objection to him going about his business, but they continued to worship him.  

Carswell left his remote home for Port au Prince soon after this event because his tumor, for the first time, was giving him pain.  It was there that Dr. Pelletier met him.  Seven years earlier the New York medicos had judged the tumor inoperable, but surgical techniques had advanced and Pelletier was willing to take a scalpel to Carswell, telling him he has a 40% or so chance of surviving the operation.  The procedure was a success, and Pelletier removed the tumor.  The tumor turned out to be an embryonic monster that emanated a chilling aura of ancient evil!  Before the monster recovered from the anesthesia used on Carswell, the doctor drowned it in a specimen jar full of alcohol.  Carswell returned to his work, and his black friends no longer worshipped him, recognizing that the god was gone.

Pelletier shows the monster to the narrator.  The final twist is that Pelletier never told Carswell that his tumor was anything out of the ordinary--the white man who probably knows more about voodoo than anybody is ironically ignorant of the most salient fact of the most shocking of all voodoo incidents, even though he is the central figure of the incident.

Whitehead's style is smooth and his images are striking, and the plot proceeds without any hitches or hiccups--thumbs up for "The Passing of a God."  

**********

Whitehead has a good mainstream literary style (like stories about white men out in the colonies among the natives so often do, the West Indian stories here remind me of Somerset Maugham) and all three of these stories work, the West Indian ones better than the American South one, which as far as I could tell could be set in any place in the world.  While solid, these stories lack any special idiosyncratic personality or ideology, and come off as well-done but standard issue horror stories.  I like today's three stories, but I don't know that I'll go out of my way to read more things by Whitehead when I have so many other authors I am more interested in, authors who have distinctive styles and/or peculiar concerns.  We'll see.