As you know, I am in a race with the Grim Reaper, trying to read at least one story from each issue of
Weird Tales before I shuffle off this mortal coil. My diet today consisted of peanut butter cups and corn chips, so probably today the Reaper is gaining on me, but I promise to eat yogurt and broccoli tomorrow.
Most of the time, when I look at the table of contents of an issue of Farnsworth Wright's essential contribution to the history of speculative fiction, I see familiar names and can read stories by men and women with whom I am already chummy, or who are at least passing acquaintances. But opening up the July 1927 issue to the table of contents pages is like walking into a room of strangers! Who are these people? Well, I'll just consult the little spoily descriptions of the stories on the TOC and pick out three that seem promising and read them, I guess.
"Gray Ghouls" by Bassett Morgan
Giant apes and startling surgery sound good. The illustration for "Gray Ghouls" shows a big gorilla cradling a shapely young lady while a man with a firearm draws a bead on said gorilla. "Bassett Morgan" is a pen name for a woman, Grace Ethel Jones, who has over a dozen short stories listed at isfdb, so there is a chance we will read her again if "Gray Ghouls" is good. According to a website maintained by Douglas A. Anderson,
Lesser-Known Writers, Jones published quite a lot of mainstream work in magazines like
Argosy,
The Smart Set and
Woman's Journal. These are all good signs.
Unfortunately, I don't like Jones' style. There are too many wacky metaphors, and the sentences are too long and clumsy and made up of disparate elements. Metaphors should make an idea easier to understand, but Jones' metaphors are actually puzzling and obscure her points, and a sentence should convey a single idea or related ideas, not just include random unrelated junk that has been nonsensically thrown together, as Jones' sentences do. Some examples:
He had been a man of character and personality, a brainy intelligence, sensual mouthed, and his good looks spoiled by a flattened nose and indulgence which over-hampered his body.
The air was hot and moist, perfumed by flowers, thick with the stench of rotting river swamp, pungent with sea tang, the mingled scents of Papua’s breasts teeming with desire, unforgettable as the hells it transcended.
Beneath were sea-gardens indescribably beautiful and menacing, tinted coral, waving fern weeds, wide-open flanges of tridacnas that can take off a man’s foot if he steps into one, pretty little fish clustering and scattering like particles of an exploding glass ball.
It is too bad Jones' writing is poor, because her plot is admirably crazed, full of shockingly twisted sex and violence.
The white authorities of Papua are dismayed to discover evidence that white tourists are purchasing shrunken heads from the natives, a bunch of cannibalistic headhunters. One shrunken head they recover has red hair! Good grief, are white people being murdered so their heads can be sold? The authorities send their bravest man, Mansey, to investigate. Mansey uncovers a horror that is beyond belief.
A red-headed Scotsman, Keith, years ago took up residence with some of the natives (whom Jones calls "blacks") and had children with some of the women. Another white man, London surgeon Mullet, is currently living among the tribe as their chief, Keith having since died. Mansey learns that Mullet left London in disgrace because of his experiments in brain transplantation, and here among the headhunters married one of Keith's biracial red-headed daughters, Sheba. Driven a little insane by life in the tropics as a lone white man surrounded by savages, and further disordered by drink, after Sheba was mauled by an ape and nearly dead, Mullet did the unthinkable--he preserved Sheba's brain by putting it in the skull of a living orangutan! He had been practicing on the natives, putting the brains of several "blacks" into the bodies of orangutans. Mullet today is in a real pickle. He wants to marry a beautiful native girl, Cleo, but Sheba is violently jealous. Mullet can't just gun down Sheba, because she, being part-white, is the leader of the orangutans with human brains, and he'd have to shoot them all, a challenging prospect. Besides, these orangutans with human brains serves as his bodyguard, allowing him to push around the murderous headhunters of whom he is chief, savages who resent him and would otherwise kill him. Jones gives us scene after scene of Sheba, an orangutan, expressing love and desire for and jealousy of Mullet, while Mullet yells at her and threatens her in an attempt to keep her under control so he can have a relationship Cleo, the hottest girl Mansey has ever seen, who of course walks around topless. Hilariously, one of Mullet's threats against Sheba is that if she doesn't behave he'll move her brain intto the body of a crocodile.

Things come to a head when another tribe of head hunters attacks the tribe of which Mullet is uneasy chief. During the confusion of the fighting, Mullet and Mansey try to escape with sexalicious Cleo. But Sheba catches up to them. Sheba grabs Cleo and tears her to pieces--so she won't suffer, Mullet shoots Cleo dead before she is dismembered. The white men shoot Sheba repeatedly, but they just have pistols, not rifles, and so before Sheba dies the jealous girl in a primate body has the strength to grab Mullet, to embrace the man she loves as she sinks into the lagoon, where a giant clam ("tridacna") seizes her foot so she and her captive lover won't float to the surface when she expires.
"Gray Ghouls" is so annoying to read that I have to give it a thumbs down, even though I want to enjoy the outrageous plot. Farnsworth Wright included the story in the September 1939 issue of Weird Tales as the Weird Story Reprint and in 1951 Donald Wollheim reprinted it in The Avon Fantasy Reader. In 2025 was published a Bassett Morgan collection edited by S. T. Joshi appeared, and "Gray Ghouls" was among its contents. I guess a lot of people are better able to overlook Jones' style than I am.
"The Impossible" by Don Robert Catlin
"Black Magic," in caps, sounds good, and "malignant Chinaman" sounds like something I'm not supposed to say, but also sounds good. Don Robert Catlin only has four stories listed at isfdb, all from 1927, and it looks like none were ever reprinted. Still, we are going to investigate this one.
Travis has not attended a meeting of the Wanderlust Club for four years. Today he returns to give a speech and a series of demonstrations. Travis declares that he has been studying Black Magic, capitalized, in Haiti, India, Egypt and China with the goal of debunking magic and freeing mankind from fear! For it is fear that gives the magician power! Travis performs feats of magic, amazing the assembled club, his aim to explain the techniques behind these tricks and liberate his colleagues from fear, which is the product of ignorance. One of Travis' (and Catlin's) rhetorical tricks is to say that when people see magic tricks they think they are seeing the impossible, but in fact they are not, because the impossible is impossible, does not exist.
A voice cries out--it is that of a "withered, ancient-looking old Chinaman," and he accuses Travis of lying. The impossible is possible says the old Chinese! This old geezer has followed Travis over thousands of miles to retrieve an ancient book Travis stole from him, a book that explains how magic tricks work. Travis hopes to teach the world these secrets and thus debunk the supernatural and defang all magicians. One of the odd conceits of this story is that a real problem facing the world is that magicians are oppressing people; I don't know, maybe that is true in the Third World?
"...down through the ages, the peoples of the earth have been as dust beneath the feet of the sorcerers, bound to them by a chain of fear hitherto unbreakable. It is my purpose to break that chain!"
Another odd conceit of "The Impossible" is that telepathy and other psychic abilities are real, and are among the techniques used by magicians to fool people into thinking magic is real. Travis and the Chinese guy have a psychic battle. Also real is pyrokinesis--the Chinese man uses his mind to burn up the ancient book, so Travis can't publish its secrets. Then Travis pulls a gun and shoots the Chinese guy three times in the chest. But before he dies, the old man draws a dagger and slashes Travis to death. Both men, both experts in "magic," which is fake, and psychic powers, which are real, die. The end.
I have to give "The Impossible" a thumbs down. Catlin's story is short but it feels long because much of its length is repetitive speeches from Travis, speeches full of nonsense about how we are all victims of magicians and how the impossible is impossible. The writing style is weak. And the whole idea of the story is ridiculous. What is the practical difference between magic and psychic powers? The world is living in fear of magicians because they can read your mind and set you on fire, but people will stop being afraid if they learn that mind-reading and pyromancy are not properly called "magic" but "psionics?" Whatever I call the powers that steal my privacy and set me on fire, I'm just as abused and just as burned up!
"The Unchained Devil" by Roscoe Gilmore Scott
Stott was, it appears, a college professor who edited a volume of Edgar Allen Poe and wrote what look like self-help books, advice books for teachers, and hymns. He only has one fiction credit at isfdb, this one. I sort of chose "The Unchained Devil" because it was short, and because I have already read so many music-related horror stories and I guess I was curious about another one.
Well, "The Unchained Devil" is kind of clunky, but it isn't terrible. And it maybe is an interesting historical document for its depiction of European immigrants to America and its attitude about Germany less than a decade after World War One. Acceptable, but barely.
Our narrator was born in Germany, a musical prodigy, a genius at the violin! But today he is in his early forties, sick and dying, barely making a living playing the "bass viol" in an orchestra here in the USA. What happened? Well, he wants to tell us before he dies, though he doubts we will believe, and he is so sick he can barely write!
Evil royals stole the narrator's father's plans for new toys, and the Prussian army threatened to conscript the narrator and abort his destiny as one of the world's great violinists, and so the narrator's family emigrated to America. The narrator's grandfather, a mysterious guy, came with them; Grandpa turns out to have wealth of which the narrator and his parents were not aware. (How is it that the narrator's parents are ignorant of the wealth of one of their own parents? This story has some odd problems. The author should have made this dude an uncle or something.) Grandpa brought with him to America a big box like a coffin. In Massachusetts, Grandpa buys a small estate and puts up what was in the coffin-like crate--a big statue of Otto von Bismarck, his hero. Grandpa declares that this statue will be their inspiration. Anyway, Dad dies before getting any traction in the toy biz and Grandpa turns out to be a spy and also dies before his charts of US ports can help Germany in the Great War.
Secret agent Gramps comes to the narrator in a dream, tells him to consult the statue of Bismarck. When the narrator does so, the face of Bismarck turns into that of the Devil! The rest of the story is about how the Devil offers to make the narrator the world's greatest violinist if he goes along with Satan's plans and threatens the narrator with humiliation and death if he goes against Satan (I think.) The plot is resolved in the current day, as the writer is sick and dying, I guess as punishment from Satan, or as payment to Satan for briefly giving him success; somehow the narrator's business relationship with Satan was hard for me to figure out. Inexplicably, a girl in her twenties, an attractive woman and a talented sculptress, falls in love with the narrator, even though he is all broken down, practically a hunchback. She recarves the statue of Bismarck into something nice, and helps cure the narrator, who recovers and is able to put aside the bass viol and take up the more prestigious violin again.
This story is kind of confusing and/or subtle, and would benefit, in my opinion, if it was more clear and explicit. The narrator never wholeheartedly embraces the Devil or Jesus, at least he doesn't tell us that he does; it seems like Satan sort of hypnotizes him and then the girl sort of interposes herself between Satan and the narrator, without the narrator himself ever making any sort of decision.
What surrender I ever made will always be a mystery to me. I can not name an hour when I ever said to imp or god that I would do thus or so.
A story in which the main character lacks agency and doesn't have clear passions or goals is rarely a compelling or entertaining story. Also, because the narrator never explicitly aligns with or against the Devil, it is not clear why bad things are happening to him, why he gets sick after his initial success. I also didn't quite understand what Grandpa wanted the narrator to do; Grandpa's ghost says "We have our work to do — you and I" and apparently Grandpop's work was to help Germany conquer the world, but what is the narrator's work that Gramps wants the narrator to do? The narrator never does anything to undermine the United States or Germany's other rivals. And what did the Devil want the narrator to do? Maybe I'm a dummy, but I also found confusing how the narrative switched back and forth between the narrator's youth, when he had those visions of Gramps and Satan, to today, when he is a twisted wreck at death's door with whom some beautiful genius falls in love.
Like I said, barely acceptable. This material is a good framework for a story, and if all the characters' motivations and goals were out in the open and we got to observe all of them making bold decisions in pursuit of those goals, I probably would have liked it.
**********
This has got to be one of the worst experiences I have ever had reading Weird Tales. Maybe I should have chosen some other stories from this issue. Hopefully the rest of 1927 will be better.